f 2008 February : Fermenting Thoughts
Fermenting Thoughts Banner

Entries from February 2008

Review: To Cork Or Not To Cork: That Is The Question

February 2nd, 2008 · No Comments

To Cork Or Not To Cork is a book that addresses a timely question: should wine be sealed with cork or some other material like plastic? I have to say that I was glad to see an entire book devoted to corkage. After surveying the ramifications of the competing materials in depth, the reader is left with the clear conviction that cork is the optimal material for wine sealing, because of it uniquely effective compression capabilities, and because of its perpetually renewable and easily biodegradable nature. Another notion I came away with, is that the small percentage cork spoilage is but a small price to pay for the long-term benefits afforded to us wine aficionados by this optimally resilient material.

As Taber points out there is reason to believe that “the perfect seal” may not be perfect. There is reason to believe that some air in the bottle provides for a better product over time, especially among the red wines. The cork’s seal was sufficiently imperfect that small quantities of air do get introduced to the bottle over time. The replacement technologies–plastic “corks” and metal screw-off caps–do provide an essentially “perfect” seal. The result? What’s know as “reduction’, a process that yields a wine that tastes, as the author phrases it, “like sulfur infused rotten eggs”.

Vast portions of the wine industry have rushed to the corner of one or the other technology. Australia has all but converted to the newer technologies. So have some of the highest end wineries in the US and (gulp) France. This has the natives in an uproar, mainly because the traditionalists–and the sommeliers of the world–view the destruction of the tableside wine presentation vignette as the surest sign that the apocalypse is indeed upon us. Tradition and snobbery, meet commerce and technology. The casual bystander should turn his eye from this grisly scene.

Where are things headed? It’s possible cork may make a comeback. The cork world has finally removed it’s blinders, trashed the arrogance and started to effect some much needed quality control processes that should improve the product.

Cheers always to the grape and to cork too.

Tags: Book Review